Chapter 4
The Lakeside Motor Inn was not where Daniel and Elena lived.
It was where he took her after she discovered the truth.
The Eastwood apartment sat thirty-eight miles from our house in a complex called Riverstone Gardens.
Daniel signed the lease as Daniel Brooks.
He used his real Social Security number with a manipulated credit report and an employer letter created from company templates.
Elena was listed as his fiancée and co-occupant.
Police searched the apartment after obtaining warrants connected to the crash, false identity, and financial evidence.
Naomi arranged for me to review photographs through my attorney, Lydia Chen, rather than enter the residence.
The second life was not temporary.
The living room held a gray sofa I had considered buying for our home.
Daniel told me it was too expensive.
A photograph above the fireplace showed him and Elena beside a lake.
He wore the navy sweater I gave him for Christmas.
Her hand rested against his chest.
The kitchen contained the same coffee brand he drank with me.
The bathroom cabinet held his prescription medication.
The bedroom closet contained half his suits.
On one nightstand sat a framed picture of an ultrasound.
Elena’s baby.
On the other sat a sympathy card.
Daniel,
We know grief never leaves, but Claire would want you to find happiness again.
The card was signed by Elena’s sister, Marisol.
Daniel had created my death deeply enough that people mourned me.
A printed obituary lay inside a desk drawer.
CLAIRE BENNETT, 34, BELOVED WIFE, EDUCATOR, AND EXPECTANT MOTHER, DIES FOLLOWING CAR ACCIDENT.
Expectant mother.
He had written that I died pregnant.
The obituary used a photograph from my university staff page.
It claimed the baby died with me.
My hands went numb.
The document had never appeared in a legitimate newspaper.
Daniel created a replica memorial website and shared it only with Elena’s family.
It included fake condolence messages from accounts he controlled.
He constructed grief as evidence.
“How long had they lived together?” I asked Lydia.
“Fourteen months.”
Longer than Elena believed I had been dead.
Daniel first met her while claiming he was separated from a seriously ill wife.
Then the wife “died.”
The transition allowed questions to disappear.
“What did he tell her happened?”
“Your car went off a bridge during heavy rain.”
The hospital call returned to me.
A crash.
Another woman.
Daniel had staged my imaginary death through the same kind of event he later used against Elena.
Inside the apartment’s second bedroom was a nursery.
Blue-gray walls.
A crib.
Stuffed animals.
A wooden sign:
GABRIEL BROOKS.
Our daughter’s nursery at home was painted pale green.
A wooden sign waited in its box:
ELEANOR BENNETT.
Daniel had assembled both cribs.
He told me the process made him emotional.
It had.
I had mistaken the source.
The apartment search also uncovered financial records.
Elena believed Daniel owned our suburban house but could not bear to live there after my death.
He promised they would move into it after their wedding.
He took her through the neighborhood once.
Pointed from the car.
“That was Claire’s garden,” he said.
My garden.
My bedroom windows.
My life displayed as a future inheritance.
Elena contributed $68,000 from savings toward a supposed mortgage payoff and wedding account.
The funds went into a company Daniel created:
Bennett-Brooks Family Holdings.
My name and his false name joined on one account.
He used Elena’s money to pay our real mortgage, his credit cards, and part of the second apartment’s rent.
May you like
He used my salary and inheritance distributions to fund Elena’s engagement ring, prenatal care, and nursery.
Each woman financed the evidence used to deceive the other.
